The character test: section 501 and Direction 123

Every visa applicant and visa holder must pass the character test. If the Department is not satisfied that you do, it can refuse your visa application or cancel your visa under section 501 of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). In some cases, cancellation is mandatory.

Character decisions are among the most serious in migration law. A refusal or cancellation can lead to detention and removal, and can stop you returning to Australia permanently.

From 31 October 2026, a new Ministerial Direction, Direction 123, sets out how these decisions must be made. It is tougher than the Direction it replaced.

Failing the character test does not automatically mean refusal or cancellation. The decision-maker must then decide whether to exercise the power, weighing the factors in Direction 123. From 31 October 2026, your ties to Australia carry less weight than they did before.

Historical image of a Sydney courtroom โ€“ the character test

When do you fail the character test?

Under section 501(6), you do not pass the character test if, for example:

  • you have a substantial criminal record. This includes being sentenced to a term of imprisonment of 12 months or more, or to two or more terms totalling 12 months or more. Suspended sentences can count;
  • you have been convicted of certain offences, such as sexually based offences involving a child, or offences committed in immigration detention;
  • you have or have had an association with a person, group or organisation that the Minister reasonably suspects has been involved in criminal conduct;
  • there is a risk that, if you were allowed to enter or remain in Australia, you would engage in criminal conduct, harass or stalk someone, or represent a danger to the community; or
  • your past and present criminal or general conduct shows that you are not of good character.

Not every charge or conviction means you fail the test. Equally, you can fail it without a conviction. Each ground has its own test.

Mandatory cancellation

If you are serving a full-time sentence of imprisonment and you have a substantial criminal record (or certain child sex offences), your visa must be cancelled under section 501(3A). There is no notice beforehand.

You can then ask for the cancellation to be revoked. The deadline is very short. You generally have 28 days from when you are notified to lodge the revocation request, with your submissions and evidence. If you miss it, you lose that opportunity.

Want advice on your situation? Book a consultation and we will look at your options before you lodge anything.

What changed with Direction 123

Direction 123 replaces Direction 110. It applies to decisions made by the Department and the Administrative Review Tribunal on or after 31 October 2026, including matters that started earlier. Submissions prepared under Direction 110 may need to be updated.

Primary considerations (now four):

  • protection of the Australian community from criminal or other serious conduct;
  • whether the conduct involved family violence;
  • the expectations of the Australian community; and
  • the best interests of minor children in Australia, including child victims.

Other considerations:

  • the strength, nature and duration of your ties to Australia;
  • the legal consequences of the decision; and
  • the extent of the impediments you would face if removed.

The key changes are:

  • Ties to Australia have moved from a primary consideration to an “other” consideration, so they generally carry less weight.
  • Family violence has a broader definition, covering more types of conduct and more types of relationships.
  • Impact on Australian business is no longer a consideration.
  • Hate speech and incitement are now expressly relevant to community expectations.

How the process works

For most non-mandatory character decisions, the Department will first send you a Notice of Intention to Consider Refusal or Cancellation. You will have a short time to respond. This is your chance to put forward your circumstances, evidence of rehabilitation, and the factors in your favour.

If a decision is made against you by a delegate, you may be able to apply to the Administrative Review Tribunal. The deadline for character decisions is much shorter than for other migration decisions, generally nine days. If the Minister makes the decision personally, there is no Tribunal review, and judicial review may be the only option.

Character and other visas

A character refusal or cancellation can affect almost every future visa. Under section 501E and other provisions, a person whose visa was refused or cancelled on character grounds is generally barred from applying for most other visas while they are in Australia, and can face permanent exclusion.

Common mistakes

  • Not disclosing convictions, including old or overseas convictions, in a visa application.
  • Missing the 28-day revocation deadline, or the nine-day Tribunal deadline.
  • Responding without evidence, or minimising the offending.
  • Relying mainly on ties to Australia, now that they carry less weight.
  • Assuming a pending criminal matter will not affect your visa.

Related guides

Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Federal Register of Legislation).

How we can help

If you have received a notice about your character, or your visa has been cancelled, contact us straight away. The deadlines in character cases are among the shortest in migration law.

Not sure where you stand? Talk it through with a lawyer.

Disclaimer: This article is general information only and is not legal advice. Immigration law and policy change often, and every case depends on its own facts. Please seek advice about your individual circumstances before making any decision.

Speak to us today More Immigration Articles, News & Updates