Section 48 bar vs Schedule 3: what is the difference?

The section 48 bar and Schedule 3 are two of the most common reasons onshore visa applications fail, and they are often confused. Both can apply when you are in Australia without a substantive visa, but they do very different things. One decides whether you can lodge an application at all. The other is a set of extra criteria you may have to meet before the visa can be granted.

We wrote this guide because the two are regularly confused. They are not the same thing, and on paper they seem unrelated: one is in the Act and controls which applications you can make, the other is in the Regulations and controls whether a visa can be granted. But they tend to arise at the same moment, when someone is in Australia on a bridging visa or without a visa after their last substantive visa has ended, and they most often come up together with onshore partner visas. It is easy to assume that clearing one means clearing the other. It does not.

This guide explains the difference between the section 48 bar and Schedule 3, how they interact, and what that means for your options.

The short version

Section 48 barSchedule 3
What it isA limit on which visas you can apply for onshoreExtra criteria for the visa to be granted
Where it comes fromSection 48 of the Migration Act 1958Schedule 3 of the Migration Regulations 1994
What triggers itA visa refusal, or certain cancellations, since you last entered Australia, and you now hold no substantive visaApplying for certain visas onshore while you hold no substantive visa
Do you need a refusal?Yes, or a cancellation under certain provisionsNo. An expired visa is enough
If it appliesOnly certain visa classes can be lodged onshore. Anything else is invalidYou must meet the Schedule 3 criteria, or for some visas show compelling reasons for them not to apply
Effect if you get it wrongThe application is invalidThe visa is refused

What is the section 48 bar?

Section 48 applies if all of these are true:

  • you are in Australia
  • you do not hold a substantive visa
  • since you last entered Australia, you were refused a visa (other than a bridging visa or a character refusal) or held a visa that was cancelled under certain provisions, including sections 109 and 116.

A bridging visa is not a substantive visa.

If it applies, you can only apply onshore for the visa classes prescribed in regulation 2.12. These include onshore partner visas, protection visas (subject to separate rules), the Medical Treatment visa, the Child (Residence) visa, bridging visas and certain skilled visa classes. An application for any other visa is invalid.

The bar is tied to your time in Australia. It does not apply to applications made from outside Australia, and travelling on a bridging visa and returning does not reset it. See our section 48 bar guide for more detail.

Forest path splitting in two โ€“ section 48 bar vs Schedule 3

What is Schedule 3?

Schedule 3 contains additional criteria for certain visas when the applicant does not hold a substantive visa at the time of application. It does not require a previous refusal. A student or visitor visa that simply expired is enough.

The main Schedule 3 criteria are:

  • 3001: the application is made within 28 days after your last substantive visa ended (or another relevant day)
  • 3003 and 3004: you are not holding a substantive visa because of factors beyond your control, there are compelling reasons to grant the visa, you substantially complied with the conditions of your previous visas, and you would have qualified for the visa had you applied while you still held a substantive visa.

Most people outside the 28 days cannot meet these. For an onshore partner visa, the criteria are not applied if the Department is satisfied there are compelling reasons for not applying them. That is usually where the case is won or lost. See Schedule 3 and onshore partner visas.

Not sure whether section 48 or Schedule 3 applies to you? Get advice before you lodge.

How they interact

Because they are triggered differently, you can be affected by one, both or neither. Some examples:

  • Your student visa expired and you never had a refusal. No section 48 bar, so you are not limited to the prescribed visa classes. But if you apply for an onshore partner visa more than 28 days later, Schedule 3 applies.
  • Your visa application was refused and you are on a bridging visa while you seek review. The section 48 bar applies, so you can only lodge the prescribed visas onshore. If you lodge an onshore partner visa, Schedule 3 is also likely to apply because you hold no substantive visa.
  • You were refused a visa but you still hold another substantive visa. The section 48 bar does not apply while you hold that substantive visa, and Schedule 3 generally will not apply either.
  • You leave Australia and apply from overseas. Neither applies to an offshore application, although other criteria, such as exclusion periods, may.

An onshore partner visa is one of the few visas that can be lodged despite the section 48 bar, which is why the two rules so often come up together. Clearing section 48 only gets you a valid application. You still need to deal with Schedule 3.

Common problems

  • Assuming that because you can lodge despite section 48, you will qualify.
  • Thinking Schedule 3 only applies after a refusal.
  • Lodging a visa that is not on the regulation 2.12 list and losing the application.
  • Making a partner visa application without a compelling reasons submission.
  • Using a Bridging Visa B trip expecting it to reset the section 48 bar.

Related guides

Legislation: Migration Act 1958 and Migration Regulations 1994 (Federal Register of Legislation).

How we can help

We advise on the section 48 bar and Schedule 3, prepare compelling reasons submissions and help you choose the right onshore or offshore pathway.

Not sure where you stand? Talk it through with a lawyer.

Disclaimer: This article is general information only and is not legal advice. Immigration law and policy change often, and every case depends on its own facts. Please seek advice about your individual circumstances before making any decision.

Speak to us today More Immigration Articles, News & Updates