Judicial review of migration decisions: how it works and what to expect

Judicial review is the last step for many migration decisions. It is a court process that checks whether a decision was made lawfully. It is not a fresh look at your case, and the court cannot simply grant you a visa. Understanding that difference is the key to deciding whether judicial review is worth pursuing.

This guide explains how judicial review of migration decisions works, the strict time limits and what you can realistically expect.

What is judicial review of migration decisions?

Most migration decisions can first be reviewed on the merits by the Administrative Review Tribunal (ART). If the ART affirms a refusal or cancellation, you may be able to apply for judicial review, usually in the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia (Division 2).

The court does not decide whether you should get the visa. It decides whether the decision-maker made a jurisdictional error, meaning a legal error serious enough that the decision was not made according to law. Examples include:

  • asking the wrong question or misunderstanding the law
  • failing to consider an important claim or piece of evidence
  • denying you procedural fairness, such as not putting adverse information to you
  • reaching a decision that is legally unreasonable or not supported by any evidence.

The error must also be material: there must be a realistic possibility the decision could have been different without it.

White columned court building – judicial review of migration decisions

Time limits

An application for judicial review of a migration decision must generally be filed within 35 days of the date of the decision. The court can extend that time if it is necessary in the interests of the administration of justice, but extensions are not automatic. Do not assume you can file late.

If you did not apply to the ART in time, judicial review is usually not a substitute. The High Court has warned that its original jurisdiction should not be used to get around a missed Tribunal deadline.

Has the ART affirmed your refusal? Time is short. Book a consultation.

What happens if you win?

If the court finds a jurisdictional error, it usually sets the decision aside and sends the matter back to the ART to decide again. The ART then reconsiders your case, which may lead to a different result, but it is not guaranteed.

Costs and risks

If you lose, you will usually be ordered to pay the Minister’s legal costs, which can be significant. That is why it is important to get advice on whether there is a real legal error before you file.

While judicial review is pending, you may need to consider your bridging visa position and any other options, including a request for Ministerial intervention where available.

Common problems

  • Treating judicial review as a second merits review and arguing the facts again.
  • Filing late without a strong explanation for the delay.
  • Grounds that identify an error but not why it was material.
  • Not attending the ART hearing, then trying to fix the problem in court.

Related guides

Legislation: Migration Act 1958 (Federal Register of Legislation).

How we can help

We assess ART decisions for legal error, advise on whether judicial review is worth pursuing and act in judicial review proceedings.

Not sure where you stand? Talk it through with a lawyer.

Disclaimer: This article is general information only and is not legal advice. Immigration law and policy change often, and every case depends on its own facts. Please seek advice about your individual circumstances before making any decision.

Speak to us today More Immigration Articles, News & Updates